Lifestyle Sports: Latest from Food Politics: The MAHA Strategy report: two leaked versions

By Marion Nestle

August 19 2025

The MAHA Strategy report: two leaked versions

The big news in my world last week was the leaking of drafts of the forthcoming MAHA strategy report.

At least four reporters sent me copies for comments.

Leaked version dated August 6 (highlighted to indicate food issues)
Leaked version dated August 11 (no highlights)

I did not do a careful comparison. The main difference seems to be that the earlier version had this useful graphic about MAHA’s strategic intentions.

All of this may change when the final report is released, but here are my initial thoughts on its food sections.

First, the background: The first report, despite the hallucinated references, was a strong indictment of this country’s neglect of the health of our children. It stated the problems eloquently. It promised that the second report would state policies to address those problems.

As for this report: No such luck.

It states intentions, but when it comes to policy, it has one strong, overall message: more research needed.

Regulate? Not a chance, except for the long overdue closure of the GRAS loophole (which lets corporations decide for themselves whether chemical additives are safe).

Everything else is waffle words: explore, coordinate, partner, prioritize, develop, or work toward.”

One good thing: the report mentions marketing to children, but only to “explore development of industry guidelines.” Nothing about regulation. This is too little too late. We know what food marketing does to kids. It’s way past time to stop it.

A few comments on specific issues mentioned.

“USDA will prioritize precision nutrition research…” USDA? NIH is already doing that, and it is the antithesis of public health research, the kind that really will make Americans healthier.
The report emphasizes color and other chemical additives (we knew it would), a definition (not regulation) of ultra-processed foods, and a potential front-of-pack label (unspecified).
It says it will modernize infant formula (really? how?), and will work to increase breastfeeding (again, how?).

And then there are the contradictions:

Improve hospital food, but the administration is taking money away from hospitals.
Teach doctors about nutrition (how?)
Prioritize “whole healthy foods” in nutrition assistance programs (but cut SNAP and WIC)
Expand EFNEP (but eliminate SNAP-ED)
Promote healthy meals in child care settings (also defunded)
Encourage grocery stores in low-income areas (how?)

How are they going to do this? It doesn’t say.

Are there any teeth behind it? It doesn’t look like this is anything more than voluntary (and we know how voluntary works with the food industry; it doesn’t). None of this says how or has any teeth behind it.

And oh no! MAHA boxes. I’m guessing these are like what got given out—badly—during the pandemic.

Resources

Politico: it published the first leak. Its current headline: “quite industry friendly”
Stat News (I’m quoted): This covers the entire report and emphasizes the reneging on trying to reduce pesticides in response to industry lobbying
New York Times (I’m quoted): also a much longer story emphasizing the pesticide problem
Washington Post: also emphasizing ag issues
CNN (I’m quoted): lots on processed foods, as well
Center for Science in the Public Interest:

It is striking that the leaked Make America Healthy Again (MAHA) Strategy Report, like its AI-assisted predecessor, embodies much of the idiosyncratic beliefs about food and drugs of one person: Robert F. Kennedy, Jr. He might be right about food dyes, but the report’s recommendations to alter our vaccine framework, restructure government agencies, and promote meat and whole milk are going to promote disease, not health…

The report…seems to twist itself into knots to make it clear that it will not be infringing upon food companies….But we also need to judge the administration by what it does, not what it says. And the administration’s attacks on SNAP, Medicaid, the health insurance exchanges, and the FDA and USDA workforces are poised to make America sicker, hungrier, and more at risk from unsafe food.

John Oliver on the MAHA movement’s lack of genuine policy initiatives (I’m quoted!) Do not miss this one.

The post The MAHA Strategy report: two leaked versions appeared first on Food Politics by Marion Nestle

Coming Soon: What to Eat Now

My new book What to Eat Now is a field guide to food shopping in America, and a treatise on how to eat well and deliciously.

Forthcoming November 11, 2025

For more information and pre-orders, click here.

You can explore the full archive of this (almost) daily blog at foodpolitics.com, where you'll also find information about my books, articles, media interviews, upcoming lectures, favorite resources, and FAQs.